Why Nani Snubbed Ronaldo and Messi – Inside His Choice for Best Player Ever

The debate over the greatest footballer of all time (GOAT) remains one of the most enduring and divisive discussions in world football. Recently, former Manchester United and Portugal winger Nani added a fresh twist to the conversation, sparking widespread reactions after snubbing two modern-era icons - Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi.

In a light-hearted yet revealing social media activity, often referred to as a “winner stays on” game, Nani was asked to pick his favourite footballer from a list of legendary names. Instead of choosing Ronaldo or Messi - both central to most football GOAT debates - Nani ultimately selected Brazilian great Ronaldinho. The choice highlighted his preference for flair, creativity and joy on the pitch over the statistical dominance and relentless consistency associated with modern football’s biggest stars.

Nani’s admiration for Ronaldinho is closely tied to the Brazilian’s unique playing style. Ronaldinho was celebrated not only for his goals and trophies, but also for his embodiment of “pure football”. His dazzling footwork, inventive playmaking and infectious joy inspired an entire generation of players and fans. For many, including Nani, Ronaldinho’s influence goes beyond numbers, emphasising the emotional and aesthetic impact a footballer can have on the game.

Ronaldinho’s peak years at FC Barcelona ushered in one of the club’s most thrilling eras, blending individual brilliance with team success. While his trophy cabinet may not match that of Messi or Ronaldo, his legacy among fellow professionals remains profound, rooted in the way he changed how football was played and enjoyed.

Although Nani’s choice may seem controversial, it reflects a broader sentiment shared by some former players and football analysts. While Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi are widely acknowledged as symbols of elite excellence across generations, defining the “best ever” often depends on personal criteria. For some, Ronaldinho’s cultural influence and impact on footballing expression outweigh achievements measured purely by goals and awards.

Cristiano Ronaldo’s goal-scoring records, physical longevity, and competitive success are unmatched in many respects; meanwhile Messi’s blend of playmaking, goals, and team success sets him apart in the modern era. Yet, in debates about football as art, Ronaldinho’s name frequently surfaces as a testament to how deeply subjective “greatness” really is.

The Ronaldo vs Messi GOAT debate continues to dominate headlines and fan discussions worldwide. FIFA awards, player rankings and expert analyses consistently keep both superstars at the centre of global football conversations. For instance, Angel Di María has publicly hailed Lionel Messi as the greatest due to his natural talent, while also acknowledging Ronaldo’s professionalism and immense impact on the sport.

Similarly, even beyond Nani’s comments, other legends have excluded Ronaldo and Messi in favour of earlier greats. Ronaldinho himself named Pelé as the best ever in a separate interview underscoring how generational perspectives influence opinion.

Nani’s GOAT selection reveals not only his personal football philosophy but also highlights a deeper truth about sporting legacies: greatness isn’t measured by stats alone. It’s shaped by the memories, emotions, and joy that a player brings to the game. Whether fans agree with Nani or not, his pick reminds us that football’s beauty often lies beyond spreadsheets and trophies.