Aadhaar Card Update: Delhi High Court Says Aadhaar Is Not Valid Proof of Date of Birth, Employee Cannot Be Retired on This Basis

Newspoint

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has issued an important clarification regarding the use of Aadhaar cards as proof of date of birth. The court has ruled that Aadhaar is an identity document and cannot be treated as conclusive evidence of a person’s birth date. It also clarified that an employee cannot be forced to retire solely on the basis of the date of birth recorded on their Aadhaar card.

The ruling came while hearing a dispute involving JJ Electronics and its former employee, Rozamma Joy. The company had ended her employment by relying on the birth year mentioned on her Aadhaar card. However, her Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) records showed a different date of birth.

The High Court upheld the Labour Court’s decision and rejected the company’s petition, providing relief to the employee.

Delhi High Court Rejects Company’s Petition Over Aadhaar Date of Birth

The dispute began when JJ Electronics terminated Rozamma Joy’s employment, claiming that she had reached 58 years of age. The company relied on the year 1959 mentioned on her Aadhaar card to support its decision.

However, her ESIC records listed her date of birth as May 20, 1960. The difference between the two records became the central issue in the employment dispute.

JJ Electronics challenged the Labour Court’s decision before the Delhi High Court. However, in an order dated November 13, Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri dismissed the company’s petition.

The court agreed with the Labour Court that Aadhaar is legally recognised as proof of identity but cannot be considered conclusive proof of date of birth.

Why Aadhaar Card Cannot Be Used as Conclusive DOB Proof

During the proceedings, the Delhi High Court also referred to a 2018 clarification issued by the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI).

According to the directive, the date of birth recorded on an Aadhaar card may be based either on supporting documents submitted by the applicant or on self-declaration.

This means that the date mentioned on Aadhaar cannot automatically be treated as definitive evidence of a person’s actual birth date in every legal or employment-related matter.

The court’s observation highlights the distinction between establishing someone’s identity and verifying their date of birth through appropriate official records.

Company Directed to Pay Employee’s Pending Salary

The High Court also examined whether Rozamma Joy had actually reached the applicable retirement age when the company terminated her employment in 2017.

After considering the available records, the court found that she had not attained the retirement age at that time. Therefore, the company was not justified in ending her employment by relying on the different birth year mentioned on her Aadhaar card.

The court further observed that JJ Electronics had failed to follow the necessary provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act while terminating her services.

Consequently, the termination was held to be unlawful, and the Labour Court’s direction to pay her outstanding wages was upheld.

The judgment reinforces that employers cannot rely solely on Aadhaar details to determine an employee’s retirement age when the date of birth is disputed. Appropriate records and applicable legal procedures must be considered before taking such decisions.

Disclaimer:

This article is based on the court proceedings and details provided in the source material. It is intended for general news and informational purposes and should not be considered legal advice. The applicability of the judgment may depend on the facts and circumstances of individual cases. Readers facing similar employment or documentation disputes should consult a qualified legal professional.