Aadhaar Card Is Not Proof of Date of Birth: Significant Ruling by High Court

Newspoint

The Delhi High Court has clarified that the date of birth recorded on an Aadhaar card is not conclusive proof of age. JJ Electronics cannot retire an employee based solely on the year of birth mentioned in their Aadhaar card.

A significant development has emerged from the Delhi High Court regarding Aadhaar cards. The High Court has explicitly stated that an Aadhaar card cannot be considered definitive proof of one's date of birth. The court noted that an Aadhaar card serves only as proof of identity, not as proof of date of birth. Consequently, an employee cannot be retired based solely on the date recorded in their Aadhaar card.

This matter concerns JJ Electronics and its employee, Rojamma Joy. The company had terminated her employment, claiming she had reached the age of 58 based on the year of birth—1959—recorded on her Aadhaar card. However, the employee’s ESIC (Employees' State Insurance Corporation) records indicated her date of birth as May 20, 1960. The High Court upheld the decision of the Labour Court and dismissed the company's petition.

What is the case about?

Rojamma Joy worked as a 'finishing man' at JJ Electronics. The company discovered a discrepancy between the date of birth on her Aadhaar card (1959) and her ESIC records (1960). Relying on the date mentioned in the Aadhaar card, the company retired her, asserting that she had reached the age of retirement.

Following this, Joy filed a complaint with the Labour Court, challenging her termination. She sought reinstatement and the payment of outstanding wages. The Labour Court refused to accept the Aadhaar card as conclusive proof of her date of birth. Instead, it accepted the date of May 20, 1960, as recorded in the ESIC documents, and directed the company to pay her outstanding wages and other associated benefits.

What did the High Court say?

JJ Electronics had challenged the Labour Court's decision in the Delhi High Court. In an order issued on November 13, Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri dismissed the company's petition. The court stated that under the Aadhaar Act, the document is recognized as proof of identity, not as conclusive proof of one's date of birth.

The court also referred to a 2018 circular issued by the UIDAI, which clarifies that the date of birth recorded in an Aadhaar card may be based on documents submitted by the cardholder or on information provided by the individual themselves.

Company ordered to pay outstanding wages

During the proceedings, the High Court observed that in 2017, Rojamma Joy had not yet reached the age of retirement. Therefore, the company could not terminate her employment based on a different birth year recorded in her Aadhaar card. The court further noted that the company failed to comply with the mandatory provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act while terminating her employment. Consequently, the termination was deemed illegal, and the Labour Court’s order directing the payment of outstanding wages was upheld.