No tax on capital gains from sale of MFs by Mauritius funds: HC

Newspoint
New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has held that capital gains from the sale of units of equity-oriented mutual funds (MFs) by Mauritius-based investors are not taxable in India, as MF units cannot be equated with equity shares under the India-Mauritius tax treaty. The ruling is likely to provide relief to Mauritius-based foreign institutional investors.

Interpreting the India-Mauritius Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA) on capital gains arising from the sale of equity-oriented MF units, a division bench comprising Justices Subramonium Prasad and Renu Bhatnagar clarified that such gains are taxable only in Mauritius, while gains from the sale of shares are taxable in India.

The ruling came in a tax dispute involving Emerging India Focus Funds, a Mauritius tax resident. The company had invested in shares and debentures of Indian companies and made capital gains of ₹593.48 crore from the sale of equity-oriented MF units in assessment year 2022-23. However, the income tax department treated 65% of the gains, amounting to ₹385.76 crore, as taxable in India under Article 13(3A) of the India-Mauritius tax treaty.

Ruling in favour of the assessee, the court said a holder of MF units is not the owner of equity shares in a company and does not enjoy the rights or bear the liabilities of shareholders. Therefore, gains made by Emerging India from selling MF units were not taxable in India.

"A unit holder of a mutual fund is, therefore, not a shareholder of the company. The unit holder only holds a unit in a fund which invests in shares or in any other securities," the court said, rejecting the income tax department's argument that capital gains from MF units should be classified as gains from the underlying Indian shares.

Referring to various provisions of the tax treaty specifying the categories of income taxable in the two countries, the court rejected the department's argument for a purposive interpretation of the treaty and held that its provisions must be interpreted strictly.

"The true intention of the contracting nations was to gain taxes arising out of the transaction of shares in Mauritius only and not in India, and for any other property, it was agreed that the same will be taxed only in the contracting state of which the alienator is a resident and in this case it is Mauritius," the court said.

The agreement between India and Mauritius was aimed at helping investors avoid double taxation, preventing evasion of income and capital gains taxes, and encouraging investments in mutual funds, the judgment stated.

The assessee had filed objections before the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP), arguing that the capital gains were not covered under Article 13(3A), as the provision applied only to the alienation of shares and not MF units.

The DRP held that once units of equity-oriented MFs were treated as shares, the entire capital gains would be taxable under Article 13(3A) of the India-Mauritius DTAA. However, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), in June 2025, set aside the panel's findings. The high court has now upheld the tribunal's decision, holding that the treaty specifically covers gains from the sale of shares.