Historic Xi-Trump-Putin meeting in China on Apec Summit sidelines: What's on agenda and what will be key challenge
PTC News Desk: A historic trilateral meeting between US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin has begun in Shenzhen, China. Opening the unprecedented meeting, Trump said the three leaders were "making history".
"We are going to discuss the war between Russia and Ukraine," Trump said as the meeting got underway.
The leaders of the world's three major nuclear powers sat around a large round table inside a villa in Shenzhen, on the sidelines of an Asia-Pacific summit. Each leader delivered opening remarks.
Putin said the three countries shared several interests in resolving regional conflicts, including the Russia-Ukraine war.
Xi, who was presiding over the meeting according to Chinese state media, did not directly mention Ukraine. Instead, he said, "History tells us that when major powers live in harmony, the world is at peace.
Analysts believe the meeting is unlikely to result in any major agreements because of deep differences among the three countries over Ukraine, Iran, nuclear weapons and trade. However, the meeting has raised concerns among smaller nations, which fear that their interests could be overlooked.
Before the trilateral meeting, Trump held separate discussions with Xi and Putin, referring to both leaders as friends.
Trump said that he and Xi shared strong concerns about ensuring the uninterrupted flow of oil through the Strait of Hormuz, which has been disrupted by the ongoing war involving Iran. However, Xi has not mentioned either Ukraine or Iran in his public remarks during the two-day summit.
Patricia Kim, a foreign policy fellow at the Brookings Institution, said China would be reluctant to broker a settlement in Ukraine because neither Kyiv nor European leaders were participating in the discussions.
She said Xi had described the Russia-Ukraine war as primarily a European issue, making Beijing even less willing to take responsibility for resolving it.
Nuclear arms control to be a key challengeTrump has insisted that nuclear arms control should be a central subject of the summit. However, China has repeatedly resisted joining nuclear negotiations with the US and Russia, whose nuclear arsenals are significantly larger.
"It's not an easy thing to do – give them up," Trump told Xi and Putin at the beginning of the meeting.
According to Craig Singleton of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, all three leaders have reasons to appear together, but reaching substantive agreements will be difficult because of their differences over Ukraine, Iran, nuclear weapons, trade and China's military expansion.
Singleton said a photograph of the three leaders together could benefit all of them, but agreeing on the actual agenda would be far more challenging.
US-China trade tensions remainTrump's meeting with Xi comes after the two countries extended their trade truce earlier this month. However, tensions remain over reports that Nvidia chips are being diverted to China through Southeast Asian countries.
The reports have raised questions about the effectiveness of US export restrictions and the future of China's access to advanced technology.