Italian Politician Criticizes Local Leaders Comments on Indian Democracy

Newspoint
New Delhi, November 16 (Daily Kiran) : Italian politician Deborah Bergamini, a prominent member of the ruling Forza Italia party, has taken issue with comments made by Giacomo Filibeck, the Secretary-General of the Party of European Socialists (PES). Filibeck had criticized Indian democracy during a meeting held by the Indian National Congress in Telangana, where he claimed that voting was being compromised in India.
Bergamini responded strongly, asserting that a country with 970 million voters does not need lessons on democracy from Europe. She emphasized that India has its own established political institutions and an independent judiciary capable of resolving internal disputes and grievances. In a post on her Facebook account, Bergamini highlighted Filibeck's remarks, which came at a time when the Indian opposition was criticizing the ruling government over updates to the electoral rolls.
This process aims to remove duplicate entries and names of deceased individuals or those who have moved away. While acknowledging the right of political parties and individuals to express their concerns in a democratic society, Bergamini insisted that such claims must be supported by evidence. "In a democracy, everyone is free to make their arguments or allegations, provided they can substantiate them," she stated. Bergamini further noted that it is inappropriate for a major ally to interfere in another country’s domestic political debates, especially when that country has a "special strategic partnership" with Italy, fostering deep cooperation across various sectors.
She underscored the importance of respecting India's democratic institutions and asserted that it is unjustifiable for Europeans to preach about democracy to a nation that allows 970 million citizens the right to vote. "Any disputes or grievances should be resolved according to the established rules of democracy," she added. The controversy began following Filibeck's comments at the "India Summit 2026" held in Hyderabad on November 14, where he shared the stage with opposition leader Rahul Gandhi.
During his address, Filibeck claimed that Indian democracy was under attack and being "hijacked," echoing the Congress party's electoral slogans. In response to Filibeck's allegations, Bergamini argued that any differences or complaints related to India's electoral processes should be addressed through the country's democratic institutions and judicial system. Earlier, on the same day, Indian Home Minister Amit Shah condemned Rahul Gandhi for making "anti-India" statements at international forums, accusing him of trying to tarnish the country's image out of frustration from repeated electoral defeats.
Shah criticized the Congress for inviting leftist propagandists from around the world to the summit, asserting that Gandhi used the platform to express anti-India sentiments. He emphasized the need for grassroots work in villages rather than seeking validation through international conferences. It is important to note that India and Italy share a "special strategic partnership," which is founded on high-level political engagement, growing economic ties, and scientific collaboration.
In May 2026, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni elevated bilateral relations to the level of "special strategic partnership" based on a Joint Strategic Action Plan for 2025-2029.