Why the Big 3 Still Outshine the Dark Shonen Trio
The Big 3, consisting of Naruto , One Piece , and Bleach, is a term coined by Western anime fans to refer to the three most dominant, popular, and influential shonen titles of the 2000s. In the 2020s, however, as the shonen demographic was undergoing notable changes and its audience’s tastes shifted towards more mature, bleaker topics, a new supreme triad emerged called the Dark Shonen Trio .
Chainsaw Man, Jujutsu Kaisen, and Hell’s Paradise: Jigokurarku that make up the new-gen Dark Trio are undeniably excellent shows that reflect the modern sensibilities of shonen well. Yet, despite their novelty and the standout quality of each of these trailblazing titles, they haven’t managed to beat the iconic Big 3 and are still lacking in comparison.
All Big 3 titles take place in vastly different worlds, with Bleach’s setting being the most grounded, while Naruto and especially One Piece construct entire fantastical universes far removed from reality. Unlike their Dark Trio counterparts, the Big 3 anime don’t use their worlds as merely backgrounds to set the plot against.
Each show has the time and space to go deep into the culture, politics, and history of its respective setting, which makes their universes feel far more lived-in, nuanced, and immersive. One Piece in particular is an unrivaled masterclass of expansive worldbuilding, with Eiichiro Oda crafting a one-of-a-kind seafaring planet where every island feels distinct yet flawlessly integrated into the larger world and story.
Chainsaw Man, Jujutsu Kaisen, and Hell’s Paradise: Jigokurarku that make up the new-gen Dark Trio are undeniably excellent shows that reflect the modern sensibilities of shonen well. Yet, despite their novelty and the standout quality of each of these trailblazing titles, they haven’t managed to beat the iconic Big 3 and are still lacking in comparison.
The Big 3’s Magnificent Worldbuilding
The Dark Trio series undeniably have compelling settings: an urban fantasy world where curses lurk out of common people’s sight, a horrifying dystopia plagued by fears manifested as bloodthirsty monsters, and a supernatural version of Edo-period Japan. However, when it comes to creating complex and original fantasy worlds, the new generation of shonen anime is obviously lacking compared to its predecessors, which largely enticed fans thanks to the strength of their worldbuilding.All Big 3 titles take place in vastly different worlds, with Bleach’s setting being the most grounded, while Naruto and especially One Piece construct entire fantastical universes far removed from reality. Unlike their Dark Trio counterparts, the Big 3 anime don’t use their worlds as merely backgrounds to set the plot against.
Each show has the time and space to go deep into the culture, politics, and history of its respective setting, which makes their universes feel far more lived-in, nuanced, and immersive. One Piece in particular is an unrivaled masterclass of expansive worldbuilding, with Eiichiro Oda crafting a one-of-a-kind seafaring planet where every island feels distinct yet flawlessly integrated into the larger world and story.
Next Story